Transactions treated as supplies of services for consideration EU VAT case law
3 cases of the Court of Justice and the General Court of the European Union on this point of VAT law, from 2021 to 2026.
Search within this topicThe cases ↓
Provisions these cases interpret most
- Article 26 of Directive 2006/112/EC Supply of services · 3 of these cases
- Article 2 of Directive 2006/112/EC Subject matter and scope · 1 of these cases
- Article 56 of Directive 2006/112/EC Particular provisions · 1 of these cases
The 3 cases, most recent first
Under each case, what the Court decided, from its summary. The summaries are AI-generated and are not official documents: open the case for the Court’s own text.
T-680/25 Mercedes-Benz
Judgment · 4 November 2026 · Romania
Tooling lent free of charge to component makers is not a deemed supply, even without a direct invoicing relationship
The General Court holds that Article 26(1) of the VAT Directive does not allow the free loan of equipment by a vehicle manufacturer to a component maker to be treated as a supply of services for consideration where the component maker uses it to produce components for the vehicle manufacturer and sells them through an intermediary, so that there is no direct invoicing relationship, provided that the components are used exclusively by the vehicle manufacturer. Whether they are so used is for the referring court to check. The test is purpose, not the invoice chain.
C-607/20 GE Aircraft Engine Services
Judgment · 17 November 2022 · United Kingdom
Retail vouchers awarded free of charge to employees under a reward scheme
The free award of retail vouchers to employees under a programme designed to recognise and reward the most deserving and high-performing staff falls outside Article 26(1)(b). The scheme was dictated by the proper conduct of the business and the pursuit of profit through improved employee motivation and performance. The personal advantage to employees was merely incidental. Employees could not be certain of receiving vouchers, awards resting on strictly professional criteria applied by colleagues. Fiscal neutrality is preserved because the retailers account for output VAT on redemption. Employers running performance-based recognition schemes funded with third-party retail vouchers need not account for deemed output tax on the award, provided the scheme is genuinely driven by business objectives and any private benefit is incidental. Relevant to HR, reward and employment tax advisers, and to groups recharging vouchers between entities.
C-288/19 Finanzamt Saarbrücken
Judgment · 20 January 2021 · Germany
Company cars provided to employees and the place of long-term hiring of means of transport
Article 56(2), first subparagraph, does not apply where there is no supply of services for consideration under Article 2(1)(c). Provision free of charge, even if treated as a supply under Article 26(1)(a), is not a "hiring". Rent must be payable in money, and a benefit in kind taxed for income tax purposes will not do. Article 56(2) does apply where the employee pays rent for an agreed period exceeding 30 days and enjoys a permanent right of private use excluding others. Employers with cross-border workforces must distinguish cars given free of charge from those provided against a real monetary contribution, typically a salary deduction. Relevant to employee benefit and company car schemes, and to advisers reviewing benefit-in-kind valuations used as a VAT proxy.